RSS

What to do when FCPX failed you?

24 Jun

 

 

What do you do when FCPX failed you? I have been asking my self since Tuesday afternoon what do I do? I have had projects lined up to be edited on FCPX. I told my self FCPX was going to fix all my concerns that I had for FCP. I’ve seen the blogs that many have predicted that FCPX was supposed to be. I knew that FCPX was going to have a new layout, which I didn’t care for since I do not like change.

The day FCPX came out and the day I tried it, I hated it from the start. I couldn’t figure out how to use it. Reviews on Apples website were mixed, more hate than love. Twitter feed was blowing up by the hour, heck it even made it on nationwide T.V! Apple FCPX was not what everyone thought it was supposed to be.

At this time I knew FCP7 was hopeless for MY needs, I needed something that I could edit on that needs both my needs and the work-flows of my projects. Most of my projects come from DSLR based footage. I can’t express the pain that I have to go through when transcoding. Very much like walking on a beach of hot sand on a very sunny day!

So I decided to look at my many few options that I had to work with. The choices I were given were, AVID or Premiere Pro CS.5. Well to start I can’t stand to work on AVID, my mind was so fixed on editing on FCP I couldn’t think to back pedal to learn AVID. However Avid does fit my needs but just not able to accommodate my mental block.

So my next choice was to try Adobe Premiere Pro CS5.5 I’ve had CS5 since last May when I received a free copy of the master collection in Cannes France, but I’ve never used Premiere! However Maxim Jago Sam Hobbin a UK Adobe trainer had showed me the ropes when I was in France but I didn’t fancy the idea of having to learn another program when my heart, and mind was set on FCP.

So after letting my guard down I decided to try premiere, I opened up the timeline of Premiere, I noticed it slightly resembled FCP in a sense. However the shortcut keys were all different the lay out could be arranged like my custom layout in FCP. I started to put a slight grin on my face, I imported all my footage. I then began to cut–first thing I noticed was no transcoding! Let there be light!! I think I see pings flying!!

I then decided to dig deeper into Premiere, I come to notice that Premiere can be a little more interesting with Keyboard customization! voila! I can now edit on Premiere using FCP7 shortcuts, who would think this was possible. You can also use AVID shortcuts for those who transfer from AVID to premiere.

If you want to make PPRO a little more like FCP7, you can also take the color of PPRO and make it lighter or darker, if you want the light color skin of FCP7, lower the settings in the appearance window and BAM you got it.

If I was a car salesmen for Adobe I would tell you that Premiere is nothing like FCPX, but a lot like FCP7. ppro has DSLR workflows for those who work on DSLR workflows, but if you edit more RED workflows then they have that too! You do not need to ever render if you have a supported GFX card or the advanced hack that will allow you to never render again! The fact I have my FCP7 shortcuts, no transcoding, editing on a DSLR workflow / wonderful customer support of Adobe, made the transition from FCP to PPRO smooth and easy!

A lot of Apple users won’t give ppro a chance because you have been with FCP for years or even decades! But the fact that you have to make a choice, FCPX, AVID or PPRO. Yes you can use FCP7 for now but why? It surly is outdated, there are other tools in the tool box that does the same job but faster. Might have a different label on it but it gets the job done quicker then FCP7 why aren’t you using it?

 

Do you like to subject your self to toruture of transcoding and rendering? Then stay with FCP7, but in a years time, FCPX will be the only program apple will update, I can’t see them updating imovie2012 not after all the money they invested into FCPX, they are only halfway done with it but it still will work the same way, yes missing features but the beast will walk and talk the same way. Those same ways are what I don’t like. If I can work fast and enjoy my time with PPRO, then my time will be better spent on a software that gets the proper attention of updating that it needs. Adobe seems to do an update once per year! I can’t wait to see what CS6 will bring!

 

 

 

Advertisements
 
4 Comments

Posted by on June 24, 2011 in Uncategorized

 

Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , ,

4 responses to “What to do when FCPX failed you?

  1. Mr WordPress

    June 24, 2011 at 1:43 pm

    Hi, this is a comment.
    To delete a comment, just log in, and view the posts’ comments, there you will have the option to edit or delete them.

     
  2. Dan Nicholas

    June 25, 2011 at 5:25 am

    Thanks Joseph for sharing your thoughts. I hated the last time I used Premiere – but that was years ago. I’m hearing a lot of good things about it – esp. the Mercury engine.

    Time I gave it a shot.

     
    • jtpllc

      June 25, 2011 at 5:37 am

      In the long run, using ppro is smooth, it will be updated yearly. The designers have the interest of the arists not the soccor moms in mind. The fact that apple is trying to merge fcp7 and imovie together shows a lack of support for pro editors.

      Dan let me know what you think of ppro after you give it a shot, but to make life eaiser try and use the fcp7 shortcuts on ppro. Let me know how you make out and I’m glad I could be of some help.

       
  3. Hughes

    July 2, 2011 at 6:55 pm

    Pr 5.5 is starting to look like the direction that everybody is moving in, in spite of the fact that most people here in Hollywood edit on Media Composer on a daily basis in the “big houses”. The only question seems to be stability issues on OS X, but Adobe seem to be very proactive about addressing all these issues and reaching out to the customer base to find out what they’re thinking/feeling about the product. I would gladly move to a platform that took the thoughts and needs of its user base this seriously.

     

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: